Worked example

Truss bar forces by the method of joints

A truss with six joints and nine bars, supported by a pin and a roller, loaded by two vertical and one horizontal joint load. First we calculate the support reactions, then all the bar forces, moving from joint to joint.

The problem

Determine the support reactions and all bar forces, and state which bars are in tension and which are in compression.

The truss and the loads

3 m3 m3 m3 mAxAxAyAyDyDyF1 = 20 kNF1 = 20 kNF2 = 10 kNF2 = 10 kNF3 = 5 kNF3 = 5 kNAABBCCDDEEFF

Step 1: the support reactions

Treating the truss as a single rigid body, we write the three equilibrium equations.

Support reactions

Assumed positive directions: forces ↑ and →, moments ↺.

ΣFx = 0:
Ax + F3 = 0
Ax + 5 = 0
⇒ Ax = −F3 = −5
⇒ Ax = −5 kN (←)

ΣMA = 0:
Dy·9 − F1·3 − F2·6 − F3·3 = 0
Dy·9 − 20·3 − 10·6 − 5·3 = 0
⇒ Dy = F1·3 + F2·6 + F3·39 = 20·3 + 10·6 + 5·39
⇒ Dy = 15 kN (↑)

ΣFy = 0:
Ay + Dy − F1 − F2 = 0
Ay + 15 − 20 − 10 = 0
⇒ Ay = −Dy + F1 + F2 = −15 + 20 + 10
⇒ Ay = 15 kN (↑)

Check

ΣMD = 0:
−Ay·9 + F1·6 + F2·3 − F3·3 = 0
−15·9 + 20·6 + 10·3 − 5·3 = 0
⇒ 0 = 0 ✓

Step 2: the bar forces joint by joint

Every bar is assumed to be in tension. We always continue with a joint that has at most two unknown bar forces, because two force equations can be written for a joint. The forces of inclined bars are resolved into horizontal and vertical components; a negative result means the bar is in compression.

Bar forces are assumed to be tensile: the bar force acting on the node points away from the node, along the bar. A positive result means tension, a negative one compression.

Assumed positive directions: forces ↑ and →. The force of an inclined bar is resolved into a horizontal (x) and a vertical (y) component.

Zero-force bars

A zero-force bar carries no force. At a node without load or support: if only two bars that are not in line meet there, both are zero-force bars; if three bars meet there and two of them are in line, the third is a zero-force bar. The rules can be applied again without the zero-force bars already found.

The rules find no zero-force bar in this truss.

Equilibrium of the nodes

Node A

Unknowns at this node: SAB, SAE.

3 m3 m3 m3 mαAEαAEAABBEE

tg αAE = 33 ⇒ αAE = 45° ⇒ SAEx = SAEy

SABSABSAESAEAxAxAyAyAA
SAExSAExSAEySAEySAESAEαAEαAE

With the components instead of the inclined bar forces:

SABSABSAExSAExSAEySAEyAyAyAxAxAA

ΣFy = 0:
SAEy + Ay = 0
SAEy + 15 = 0
⇒ SAEy = −Ay = −15
⇒ SAEy = −15 kN

From the angle the other component, then from the two components the bar force SAE:

⇒ SAEx = SAEy = −15 kN
⇒ SAE = −SAEx2 + SAEy2 = −(−15)2 + (−15)2
⇒ SAE = −21.213 kN (compression)

ΣFx = 0:
SAB + SAEx + Ax = 0
SAB − 15 − 5 = 0
⇒ SAB = −SAEx − Ax = 15 + 5
⇒ SAB = 20 kN (tension)

Node B

Unknowns at this node: SBC, SBE.

SABSABSBCSBCSBESBEF1 = 20 kNF1 = 20 kNBB

ΣFx = 0:
SBC − SAB = 0
SBC − 20 = 0
⇒ SBC = SAB = 20
⇒ SBC = 20 kN (tension)

ΣFy = 0:
SBE − F1 = 0
SBE − 20 = 0
⇒ SBE = F1 = 20
⇒ SBE = 20 kN (tension)

Node D

Unknowns at this node: SCD, SDF.

3 m3 m3 m3 mαDFαDFDDCCFF

tg αDF = 33 ⇒ αDF = 45° ⇒ SDFx = SDFy

SCDSCDSDFSDFDyDyDD
SDFxSDFxSDFySDFySDFSDFαDFαDF

With the components instead of the inclined bar forces:

SCDSCDSDFxSDFxSDFySDFyDyDyDD

ΣFy = 0:
SDFy + Dy = 0
SDFy + 15 = 0
⇒ SDFy = −Dy = −15
⇒ SDFy = −15 kN

From the angle the other component, then from the two components the bar force SDF:

⇒ SDFx = SDFy = −15 kN
⇒ SDF = −SDFx2 + SDFy2 = −(−15)2 + (−15)2
⇒ SDF = −21.213 kN (compression)

ΣFx = 0:
−SCD − SDFx = 0
−SCD + 15 = 0
⇒ SCD = −SDFx = 15
⇒ SCD = 15 kN (tension)

Node C

Unknowns at this node: SCE, SCF.

3 m3 m3 m3 mαCEαCECCBBDDFFEE

tg αCE = 33 ⇒ αCE = 45° ⇒ SCEx = SCEy

SBCSBCSCDSCDSCFSCFSCESCEF2 = 10 kNF2 = 10 kNCC
SCExSCExSCEySCEySCESCEαCEαCE

With the components instead of the inclined bar forces:

SBCSBCSCExSCExSCDSCDSCFSCFSCEySCEyF2 = 10 kNF2 = 10 kNCC

ΣFx = 0:
−SCEx − SBC + SCD = 0
−SCEx − 20 + 15 = 0
⇒ SCEx = −SBC + SCD = −20 + 15
⇒ SCEx = −5 kN

From the angle the other component, then from the two components the bar force SCE:

⇒ SCEy = SCEx = −5 kN
⇒ SCE = −SCEx2 + SCEy2 = −(−5)2 + (−5)2
⇒ SCE = −7.071 kN (compression)

ΣFy = 0:
SCF + SCEy − F2 = 0
SCF − 5 − 10 = 0
⇒ SCF = −SCEy + F2 = 5 + 10
⇒ SCF = 15 kN (tension)

Node E

Unknowns at this node: SEF.

SEFSEFSAESAESBESBESCESCEF3 = 5 kNF3 = 5 kNEE
SAExSAExSAEySAEySAESAEαAEαAE
SCExSCExSCEySCEySCESCEαCEαCE

With the components instead of the inclined bar forces:

SEFSEFSCExSCExSAExSAExF3 = 5 kNF3 = 5 kNSAEySAEySBESBESCEySCEyEE

ΣFx = 0:
SEF − SAEx + SCEx + F3 = 0
SEF + 15 − 5 + 5 = 0
⇒ SEF = SAEx − SCEx − F3 = −15 + 5 − 5
⇒ SEF = −15 kN (compression)

ΣFy = 0 (check):
−SAEy − SBE − SCEy = 0
15 − 20 + 5 = 0
⇒ 0 = 0 ✓

Check

The equilibrium equations of the nodes not used yet must also be satisfied.

Node F

SEFSEFSDFSDFSCFSCFFF
SDFxSDFxSDFySDFySDFSDFαDFαDF

With the components instead of the inclined bar forces:

SEFSEFSDFxSDFxSDFySDFySCFSCFFF

ΣFx = 0:
−SEF + SDFx = 0
15 − 15 = 0
⇒ 0 = 0 ✓

ΣFy = 0:
−SDFy − SCF = 0
15 − 15 = 0
⇒ 0 = 0 ✓

Summary

BarBar forceType
SAB20 kNtension (+)
SAE−21.213 kNcompression (−)
SBC20 kNtension (+)
SBE20 kNtension (+)
SCD15 kNtension (+)
SCE−7.071 kNcompression (−)
SCF15 kNtension (+)
SDF−21.213 kNcompression (−)
SEF−15 kNcompression (−)
3 m3 m3 m3 mF1 = 20 kNF1 = 20 kNF2 = 10 kNF2 = 10 kNF3 = 5 kNF3 = 5 kN20 kN20 kN20 kN20 kN15 kN15 kN−15 kN−15 kN−21.213 kN−21.213 kN−21.213 kN−21.213 kN20 kN20 kN15 kN15 kN−7.071 kN−7.071 kNAABBCCDDEEFF

tension compression zero-force bar

More examples